Sign up for our newsletter

Once, I Went to a Foreign Policy Debate … and an Education Fight Broke Out

by Jeanne Allen
October 23, 2012

Some were confused that the presidential candidates in last night’s debate, ostensibly about foreign policy, pivoted so often to the education and the economy. I was surprised, too, but I didn’t share the view that these subjects were “off topic.” Both candidates recognize that for the U.S. to remain competitive abroad and safe at home, we must have a solid domestic foundation, including a robust education system that produces citizens who can compete in the global economy, and who are qualified to protect us.

Prior to the debate, I suggested there were two critical education reform questions that needed to be addressed – national security and competitiveness. I was pleasantly surprised that not only did the candidates address both, but that they went further, discussing the skills gap, teachers, and how education is a driver of economic success.

Some highlights:

• Governor Romney discussed the need to put parents, teachers, and kids first, and asserted that the teachers unions to get behind this principle.

• President Obama talked about the need for more math and science teachers, since American students lag many other developed nations in those subjects. He made the point that our success in these areas will determine whether we have the highly skilled workforce necessary for new business creation, and to make the U.S. attractive to investment.

• Romney talked about the lack of jobs for kids coming out of college and that we can’t fix the economy without fixing that.

• Obama said that if we don’t have the best education system in the world, we will lose our competitive edge over other countries. He argued that Romney’s budget would cut education and undermine that goal.

• Romney expresses pride in Massachusetts’ achievement record, asserting that the federal government didn’t help them get there.

Both candidates took the opportunity to press their now well-established positions – President Obama for teachers, class size and more money; and Governor Romney for standards, performance, and local control.

Whatever side of the issues you fall on, it’s a “win” when education reform enjoys such prominence in a presidential debate. Here’s hoping it stays in the forefront in the next four years.

###

For more on where Romney and Obama camps stand on critical education issues, head over to our Education and the Presidential Candidates page.

U.S. Department of Education Stifles Opportunities in Nation’s Capital

CER Press Release
Washington, D.C.
October 23, 2012

The enrollment numbers for the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program (OSP) released today show a troubling drop in the number of students being served by the program (1,584 students in 2012-2013 compared to 1,615 in SY 2011-2012). The decrease in enrollment is directly tied to the Obama Administration’s mishandling of the application process.

“Last week, the President spoke of giving students better educational opportunities. Yet his Administration has created numerous roadblocks for children in the nation’s capital to access quality choices,” said Jeanne Allen, President of the Center for Education Reform.

Congress gave the D.C. Children and Youth Investment Trust Corporation (D.C. Trust), the organization managing the federal program, an increase in program funds for up to 2,100 students. But US Department of Education (DOE) interference created uncertainty about the future of the program. For example:

• DOE failed to provide proper implementation guidance that would have permitted D.C. Trust to hold more application events.

• DOE set arbitrary deadlines for such meetings, for the evaluation and for the actual lottery, setting it at end the end of July rather than May, long after parents have made decisions about their child’s education. While D.C. Trust received nearly 1,500 new applications, only 319 were able to accept the scholarships.

• DOE prohibited D.C. Trust from taking any new applications after March 31, 2012. Parents who learned late about the program or found after spring testing that their child’s education was not meeting their needs are left with no options, which is at odds with the intent of the program.

“These kinds of stall and delay tactics, which reflect the Administration’s long-time opposition to the program, are simply unnecessary and unkind to the kids for whom this program was designed. Congress and the Administration agreed to continue the program despite that opposition. At that point, government was obligated to support the law,” added Allen.

Students participating in the DC OSP are posting graduation rates18 percent higher and are gaining 3.1 months of additional learning in reading than students in conventional public schools.

Research finds that the program enjoys strong parental satisfaction and support from the community.

“Yes, it’s a small program, but it is very popular. It is saving lives and helping children trapped in failing schools – a fate assigned them to by virtue of their zip code. President Obama knows the DC OSP is good. In fact, his daughters attend a school participating in the program.

“Today’s release on the DC OSP provides yet another example of bureaucracy at its best. It’s time to put politics aside and give all parents the power to make smart decisions about their children’s education,” Allen concluded.

Daily Headlines for October 23, 2012

Schools Face Test From Voters
Wall Street Journal, October 23, 2012

Voters in five states will decide next month whether to raise taxes to help fund public schools, part of a slew of ballot initiatives this year that reflect the intensifying nationwide battle over how to run government-funded schools.

Study Finds Obama’s Race To The Top Program Too Costly For Schools
Daily Freedman, NY, October 23, 2012

The implementation of President Barack Obama’s Race to the Top initiative in New York state is an expensive venture that may move public education in the state backward, according to SUNY New Paltz’s Center for Research, Regional Education and Outreach.

Should State Education Chiefs Be Elected?
Stateline, October 23, 2012

If it were up to Walter Dalton and Pat McCrory, they’d have a little less company on the ballot in North Carolina this year. In particular, they wouldn’t be sharing space with candidates for State Superintendent of Public Instruction.

FROM THE STATES

ARKANSAS

The Billionaire Boys (And Girl) Club For Charter Schools
Arkansas Times Blog, AR, October 22, 2012

The charter school movement in Arkansas and everywhere has been accurately characterized as the Billionaire Boys Club. In Arkansas, Walton, Murphy, Stephens and Hussman money is the motive power of legislation to bust what few unions remain in Arkansas classrooms and promote charter schools (backers need not be proven) and other forms of “choice,” with vouchers the ultimate game.

CALIFORNIA

Charter To Take Over School In Parent-Trigger Case
Los Angeles Times, CA, October 23, 2012

Adelanto parents select LaVerne Elementary Preparatory Academy to operate Desert Trails Elementary School , ending months of court battles.

Near L.A. Live, Parents Press For Downtown Charter School
Los Angeles Times, CA, October 23, 2012

Residents of South Park have submitted plans for Metro Charter to L.A. Unified. They say a school that their kids can walk to is too important to give up.

More Than 2 Dozen L.A. Unified Magnet Schools Are Under-Enrolled
Los Angeles Times, CA, October 23, 2012

LAUSD magnet schools have long been considered prized programs, but more than two dozen of them are under-enrolled and actively looking to fill classroom seats.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Enrollment Fails To Keep Pace With D.C. Voucher Funds
Washington Times, DC, October 22, 2012

A decision this year to add nearly $5 million in funding for federal vouchers that help low-income families in the District send their children to private schools is not guaranteed to result in higher enrollment under the program than last school year, according to preliminary data.

FLORIDA

Gov. Scott To Push Against Spending Cuts At Fort Myers Education Summit
News Press, FL,October 23, 2012

Scott, a featured speaker, will outline an education agenda that address new academic standards, teacher accountability, funding cuts and charter schools, according to a draft provided to the Miami Herald.

Rick Scott’s Education Priorities: Keep Funding Steady, Expand Charter Schools
Miami Herald, FL, October 23, 2012

The Republican governor has crafted a set of education proposals to send to the Legislature in the spring with the goal of better preparing students for college and jobs.

Academy Seeks To Avoid $81K In City Fees For New Campus
Ocala Star Banner, FL, October 22, 2012

A Francis Marion Military Academy official said Monday he feels the charter school has become the latest pawn in a war between the city of Ocala and the School District over stormwater and fire service fees.

GEORGIA

Former Mayor” ‘No’ to Amendment One’
Savannah Morning News, GA, October 23, 2012

Citizens are being asked to vote on Nov. 6 for or against an amendment to the Constitution of Georgia that would expand the power of state government over local education and lead to a dual school system.

Former School Board Member: ‘Yes’ on Amendment One
Savannah Morning News, GA, October 23, 2012

The Savannah/Chatham Board of Education’s opposition to the proposed constitutional amendment to the Georgia Constitution is understandable but not logical.

Georgia Group Supports Charter School Amendment
Albany Herald, GA, October 22, 2012

Georgia voters will decide Nov. 6 if charter schools in the state will continue to exist in a kind of limbo.

Charter School Amendment Is More About ‘How’ Than ‘What’
Macon Telegraph, GA, October 23, 2012

Rep. Edward Lindsey, R-Atlanta, majority whip in the Georgia House of Representatives says he finds himself bordering between “amused and disturbed” by opponents of the charter school amendment, which is set for a vote on Nov. 6.

IDAHO

Idaho TV Ads Prompt Lawsuit
Spokesman Review, WA, October 23, 2012

Idaho Secretary of State Ben Ysursa went to court Monday, seeking to force a defiant secret-donations group to reveal the source of more than $200,000 spent on statewide TV campaign commercials backing three controversial school reform measures.

KANSAS

Democrats Create Own Kansas School Online Site
Garden City Telegram, KS, October 23, 2012

Kansas legislative Democrats on Monday launched their own online survey on schools to counter a new website created by Republican Gov. Sam Brownback’s administration.

LOUISIANA

State Superintendent Drawing Ire
Monroe News Star, LA, October 23, 2012

At least two members of the Louisiana Senate and Governmental Affairs committee believe State Superintendent John White lied to the committee during his confirmation hearing in May, and they want him to answer for it.

MARYLAND

HCEA Requests Withdrawal From Race To The Top
Baltimore Sun, MD, October 22, 2012

The Howard County Education Association last week formally requested the Board of Education withdraw from Race to the Top, a controversial federal program tied to teacher evaluations based on student performance on state assessments — evaluations that are now law.

MASSACHUSETTS

Marshall Elementary Proposed As Charter School
Boston Globe, MA, October 22, 2012

Boston school officials announced Monday that they intend to tap an education-management company to convert the Marshall Elementary School in Dorchester into a charter school next fall, under a proposal to boost student achievement at the academically struggling school.

MICHIGAN

Tougher Rules See Grad Rate Slip
Detroit News, MI, October 23, 2012

Tougher high school graduation requirements have caused graduation rates in Michigan to drop among lower-achieving students, says an analysis released Monday.

Laid-Off DPS Teachers Can Have Their Performance Scores Reviewed
Detroit Free Press, MI, October 22, 2012

Teachers who have been laid off as a result of their 2012 performance evaluations can request a review of their scores, Detroit Public Schools announced in a news release today.

MINNESOTA

Bridging The Gap
Minnesota Daily, MN, October 23, 2012

Minnesota has long been known as a state that values education and its importance for the future of the state. Making financial investments for K-12, as well as in our public universities, is traditionally seen as a top priority for our leaders and state lawmakers. Minnesota students’ test scores are consistently ranked among the highest in the nation.

NEW JERSEY

NJEA Boss No Fan of Newark Contract Deal
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, October 23, 2012

Vincent Giordano quietly disagrees with two key components of the tentative deal: performance benefits and peer evaluation

Judge To Rule On Camden Students’ Relocation
Courier Post, NJ, October 23, 2012

An administrative law judge will rule in several days if the state must move three Camden students to new schools outside the failing city school district.

Delaware Valley High School Board Considers Accepting Out-Of-District Choice Students
Hunterdon County Democrat, NJ, October 22, 2012

A lot of questions were asked, but no decision was made at tonight’s Delaware Valley High School Board of Education meeting about possibly accepting students under the state school choice program.

NEW MEXICO

Charter Fair Will Exhibit School Choice
Albuquerque Journal, NM, October 23, 2012

As a parent or a family looking for differing educational opportunities for children, trying to find the right school can be a somewhat daunting task.

NEW YORK

In Rochester, Randi Weingarten Makes Case For Cooperative School Reform
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, NY, October 22, 2012

American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten was in Rochester on Monday to participate in a hearing of the governor’s New NY Education Reform Commission, which is looking for ways to improve the state’s schools.

Buffalo Teachers Reject Deal To Accept Transfers In Exchange For $2,500
Buffalo News, NY, October 22, 2012

Buffalo School Superintendent Pamela C. Brown offered to give $2,500 to each of the 106 teachers affected by involuntary transfers this fall in an effort to resolve the stalemate between the union and the district over the transfers.

TENNESSEE

More Than Money Is At Stake For Metro Schools
The Tennessean, TN, October 23, 2012

Unfortunately, Metro Nashville Public Schools (MNPS) has reached an impasse with the Tennessee Department of Education. The state, despite our local school board’s efforts to reconcile the situation, has withheld $3.4 million in Basic Education Program (BEP) funds in response to the board’s repeated denials of the Great Hearts Academies charter school application.

Achievement School District Gets Jolt: Low Test Scores
Commercial Appeal, TN, October 22, 2012

Early tests results a few weeks ago showed that students in the state’s Achievement School District on average are performing at the 16th percentile in the nation in reading and math.

TEXAS

Schools, State Begin Battle In Court Again
San Antonio Express, TX, October 23, 2012

Lawyers representing hundreds of school districts challenging Texas’ school funding system argued Monday that it’s “hopelessly broken,” but a lawyer for the state said the situation isn’t as dire as the schools portray.

WASHINGTON

Give Charter Schools A Chance
The Daily News, WA, October 23, 2012

Whether or not to allow charter schools isn’t the major K-12 education issue facing Washington . The state’s biggest challenge is how to fully fund education, as the state’s Supreme Court directed in its McGeary decision earlier this year.

The Times Recommends Initiative 1240, Setting Up Charter Schools
Seattle Times, WA, October 22, 2012

Charter-school supporters claim that charters will serve the most disadvantaged students. However, the 40 schools this initiative will create will serve only 1 percent of our state’s students. Current statistics show that 37 percent of Washington students receive free or reduced price lunch, 13 percent receive special-education services and 18 percent live in poverty.

VSS Symposium: “Inventing the Future of Learning”

iNACOL’s Virtual School Symposium, titled “Inventing the Future of Learning” this year, aims to bring over 2,000 industry leaders together to learn about the latest trends, challenges and opportunities in e-learning; interact in session presentations; and gain access to the latest research and best practices reports. The conference takes place in New Orleans from Sunday, October 21 to Wednesday, October 24.

The Symposium is an invaluable opportunity for the field to “come together and share success and learn from others on the leading edge of efforts to provide students of all ages and abilities with ‘anytime, anyplace’ learning solutions,” says Susan Patrick, President and CEO of iNACOL.

You can see the full conference agenda, watch sessions online, and get information about past symposiums here. Follow and add to the discussion on twitter using #VSS12.

Update: The conference has now come to an end, but check out iNACOL’s website to watch sessions from the conference online. For a quick overview of conference content, see Six Topics from the Virtual Learning Conference.

The Final Presidential Debate

Soon the presidential candidates will meet for the last time to debate and with the topic focused on foreign policy, one may be tempted to think education has no place in the discussion. But one would be wrong. There are at least two critical education questions that should be addressed.

QUESTION 1: A recent report from former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and former Chancellor of New York city schools Joel Klein found that “Educational failure puts the United States’ future economic prosperity, global position, and physical safety at risk.” The task force behind the report argued that too many young people are not qualified for the military because they do not have an adequate level of education. Do you agree with them and how would you address the issue? READ MORE…

Post-Debate Reactions and Commentary:
Once, I Went to a Foreign Policy Debate … and an Education Fight Broke Out
A few highlights from the foreign policy debate, where both presidential candidates recognized the link between education and national security and competitiveness.

Fact check: Romney’s claims on teachers unions
Los Angeles Times reporter looks into Mitt Romney’s assertion that parents and students come first and that “the teacher unions are going to have to go behind.”

A Primer List On How Digital Learning Is Boosting Achievement

(from WiredAcademic)

This post (“How Digital Learning Is Boosting Achievement”) by Tom Vander Ark originally appeared on GettingSmart.com

A reader commented that he wanted to get on board with digital learning but had been told there wasn’t much evidence of links to achievement. That’s dead wrong.

There are hundreds of solid pieces of evidence about digital learning. It’s true that investments to put 10 million computers in American schools did little to move the achievement needle in aggregate but that’s because it was layered on top of (or as Innosight would say, crammed into) the existing batch-print model of schooling. The same can be said for doubling staffing ratios over the last thrity years.

The potential of personalized learning technology—as evidenced in the military, gaming, corporate training, and informal learning—suggest the potential going forward is much greater that what we’ve seen to date. When technology is used to extend, personalize and transform learning, it makes a world of difference.

Following are a few dozen studies that demonstrate the promise of digital learning. The list of evidence above is is by no means an exhaustive. There are over a dozen academic journals dedicated to online learning research. We’d welcome your additions or favorite sources.

1. Blended schools achieve high performance:

  • Mooresville, NC has seen an improvement of 20 percentage points—from 68 percent to 88 percent—in the portion of its students who scored “proficient” on all core-subject state exams, in the subjects of reading, math, and science in the four years since its conversion to a 1-to-1 laptop program.
  • Rocketship Education elementary schools are top performing low-income schools in California in part because of a two hour computer learning lab.
  • Carpe Diem is a rotation model blended high school, and a top math performer in Arizona.
  • KIPP Empower: 95% of kindergartners scored at or above national in math and 96% in reading, while only 9% arrived kindergarten-ready.
  • AdvancePath: 90% enrolling in the blended learning dropout prevention network are likely to earn their high school diploma.
  • Robert A. Taft Information Technology High School, Cincinnati, was  converted to a technology-focused school and saw graduation rates skyrocket from about 21% to more than 95%.

2. Hundreds of studies of online and blended learning show efficacy:

3. Technology-enable math products have boosted achievement:

4. Digital learning offers the only path to boosting achievement in this “decade of deficits”:

  • In Digital Learning Imperative, the Alliance for Excellent Education first made the case that digital learning was the only solution to the achievement gap, the fiscal gap, and the effective teacher gap.
  • A recent U.S. Department of Education Study outlined nine ways that online learning can boost productivity.
  • The Florida Tax Watch evaluation of Florida Virtual School found, in addition to student achievement gains, that FLVS is “a bargain for Florida taxpayers. Largely because it has no expenses related to transportation or construction and maintenance of physical facilities, FLVS is able to offer computer-delivered instruction at a lower per-student cost than traditional schools.”

Digital learning will boost the percentage of US students that graduate ready for college and careers.  Internationally, the digital learning revolution offers the first opportunity in history to extend quality secondary to every young person on the planet.

Venture investor Ram Shriram in a recent interview said, “There is an important change that is finally happening [in K-12] thanks to broadband ,…tablets, and the kinds of things we are building in the Cloud…these things finally allow for democratization of knowledge. We can have each child learn at his or her own pace. It allows us to spread the best teachers, and best methods everywhere. We can lower the cost of education for those who are less able to afford it.”

Daily Headlines for October 22, 2012

Obama Ad Blasts Romney Over Teachers
USA Today, October 20, 2012

President Obama’s campaign is playing the education card against Mitt Romney with a new ad attacking him over teachers and class size.

How to Measure a Teacher’s Effectiveness
New York Times, NY, October 21, 2012

Re “Want to Ruin Teaching? Give Ratings” (Op-Ed, Oct. 15): I couldn’t agree more with Deborah Kenny that evaluating teachers with high-stakes tests is a dreadful idea.

FROM THE STATES

ARKANSAS

Blytheville To Hold Public Hearing On Conversion Charter
Courier News, AR, October 20, 2012

Blytheville School District will be holding a public hearing Monday to announce its plans to seek a district conversion charter for Blytheville High School.

CALIFORNIA

‘Choices’ Opens New Doors For Students At Failing LAUSD Schools
Daily Breeze, CA, October 20, 2012

Most of the parents who sign up for LAUSD’s Choices program hope to send their child to a specialty magnet – a performing arts program for an aspiring actor, perhaps, or a medical academy for a would-be doctor.

Parent Trigger Advocates, Opponents Struggle Over Adelanto Children’s Future
Redlands Daily Facts, CA, October 21, 2012

Inside Christina Purcell’s classroom at Desert Trails Elementary School , there was no hint of the political turmoil going on outside, just a few hundred feet away.

Charter Seeks Student Improvement In Proposed D-49 Transfer
Colorado Springs Gazette, CO, October 21, 2012

As a large, statewide online school seeks to transfer its state charter to growing Falcon School District 49, east of Colorado Springs , one brick-and-mortar charter school may be considering an exit.

CONNECTICUT

Education Reform Gains Local, National Attention
Yale Daily News, CT, October 22, 2012

With the November elections in two weeks and a debate over the direction of the country’s school system taking place nationwide, ongoing education reform in New Haven has become the subject of praise from local, state and national political officials.

Education Reform Leader Backs Plan To Appoint Bridgeport Board Of Ed
CT Post, CT, October 21, 2012

A national leader in education reform Sunday offered his support for the city’s plan to replace the elected Board of Education with a new board appointed by the mayor.

FLORIDA

Charter School Companies, Online Learning Outfits Try To Wield More Influence In Tallahassee
Tampa Bay Times, FL, October 22, 2012

In the looming battle for public education dollars, Jon Hage has launched a pre-emptive strike.

GEORGIA

Amendment Supporters, Opponents Clash In Debate
Savannah Morning News, GA, October 22, 2012

The opponents and supporters of the charter-school amendment agree on something: The issue is about money and control, according to comments made Sunday on statewide television.

Ga. Officials Defend Charter School Politicking
Marietta Daily Journal, GA, October 22, 2012

Deal is among the amendment backers who argue it’s a matter of offering more educational options. State Schools Superintendent John Barge, along with many local superintendents and school board members, lead the opposition. They say the amendment would strip power from local school boards that now can approve or reject applications for charters and could siphon money from existing schools.

Charter School Fight In Washington Has Parallels To Ga.
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, October 21, 2012

On a recent fall day here, Melissa Westbrook and Shannon Campion settled into high chairs behind a small table in the basement studio at cavernous Seattle City Hall .

Yes to Charter Schools
Macon Telegraph, GA, October 21, 2012

On Nov. 6, voters will be asked whether the state should be able to approve charter schools. Yes the state should. You should vote yes.

Charter Amendment Facts Differ From Campaign Rhetoric
Athens Banner-Herald, GA, October 20, 2012

Of the two constitutional amendments on this fall’s ballot, the one dealing with charter schools has generated the most attention and confusion.

INDIANA

Controversial Policies Spark Challenge In Indiana School Superintendent Race
Evansville Courier & Press, IN, October 22, 2012

After stepping into the Indiana superintendent of public instruction’s office, Republican Tony Bennett said he has faced opposition with an intensity he never would have predicted four years ago.

KANSAS

Kan. Ed Board Candidate Wants To Ease Path Into Classroom
Topeka Capital Journal, KS, October 21, 2012

A Kansas man who operates an online tutoring service as “Mr. X, Mentor of Mathematics” is running for the Kansas State Board of Education in hopes of making it easier for professionals outside the public school system to become teachers.

KENTUCKY

Kentucky School Officials Bracing For Fallout From Lower Test Scores
The Courier-Journal, KY, October 21, 2012

Parents be warned: Your child’s results from Kentucky’s rigorous new statewide tests will be released within the next few weeks — and somewhat by design, the outcome is expected to be grim.

LOUISIANA

Magnet Schools Host Event To Draw In 2013-14 Students
The Advocate, LA, October 22, 2012

Hundreds of parents and children crammed aisles and corridors Saturday in Cortana Mall where students from 33 magnet and gifted and talented programs at East Baton Rouge Parish public schools recruited and wooed shoppers with song, dance, drama and robotics demonstrations Saturday.

Educators Criticize Evaluation System
Opelousas Daily World, LA, October 21, 2012

An increasing number of educators say Louisiana’s evaluation system makes it more likely teachers at high-achieving public schools will get poor reviews, threatening their job security.

MARYLAND

Md. State Board Of Education’s New President Has Big Demands
Washington Post, DC, October 21, 2012

As a former board member of Maryland’s second-largest public school system and the current president of a community college, Charlene M. Dukes is considered by many education officials to be a natural choice to chair the board that sets policies for all of Maryland ’s public schools.

MASSACHUSETTS

MCAS and Charter Schools
Boston Globe, MA, October 21, 2012

I read your article (“Charter students score well on MCAS tests,” Sunday, Sept. 23) with great interest concerning the success of charter schools verses their local public school district.

At Roxbury Charter School One Goal Stands Out: Get Our Kids To College
The Standard-Times, MA, October 21, 2012

Shortly before 8 a.m. on a recent Friday, the front lobby of City on a Hill, a Roxbury-based charter high school, was full of laughing, boisterous teenagers, their voices a cacophony in the modern entry space.

Mayor Menino Describes Proposed School Assignment System
Boston Globe, MA, October 21, 2012

Our city is deep in conversation on efforts to create a new school assignment system. As many parents know and as we have heard loud and clear today’s system is too complicated, frustrating, and unpredictable for too many of our families.

MICHIGAN

State Slams Oakland Schools For Wide Achievement Gap
The Oakland Press, MI, October 22, 2012

There is a growing standoff between some of Oakland County’s high performing districts and the Michigan Department of Education over the state’s labeling some of their schools as having an achievement gap.

NEW JERSEY

Moran: Newark Teacher Union’s Chief Backs Groundbreaking Reform
Star-Ledger, NJ, October 21, 2012

The contract gives his teachers the chance to earn $5,000 bonuses if they can show they are highly effective, and double that if they agree to teach in a struggling school. Teachers who fill shortages in subjects such as math and science can get another $2,500.

Lawmakers Seek To End N.J. Takeover Of Schools
The Record, NJ, October 20, 2012

Paterson would gain control of its public school system for the first time in 21 years under legislation introduced by Democrats that also would limit future state takeovers to five years, lawmakers announced Friday.

Move to Nov. Has Major Effect On N.J. School Races
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, October 22, 2012

New Jersey school board candidates, who typically spend just a few hundred dollars per election, are finding it’s a different world this year.

NEW MEXICO

Test Scores No Panacea for Teacher Evaluations
Albuquerque Journal, NM, October 22, 2012

We appreciate the Journal’s editorial about the dedicated teachers at Susie Rayos Marmon Elementary who are working on their National Board Certification. We couldn’t agree more.

NEW YORK

Another Charter School Test Passed
Wall Street Journal, October 19, 2012

Eight of New York City’s top elementary and middle schools are charters—and four of the charters are in Harlem .

Kingston Teachers Anxious About New Evaluation System; Superintendent Paul Padalino Seeks To Calm Fears
Kingston Daily Freeman, NY, October 22, 2012

Good teachers have nothing to fear from the state’s new evaluation system, the Kingston schools superintendent says.

Kingston High School ‘Academies’ Revamp Set For Fall Launch
Kingston Daily Freeman, NY, October 22, 2012

Kingston High School is currently organized as a traditional “comprehensive high school,” Manuel said, which is a category for high schools that serve between 1,000 and 5,000 students, offer a comprehensive array of programs, and allow students to follow many paths to graduation.

NORTH CAROLINA

CMS, Other Charlotte-Area School Districts In Race For Federal Bucks
Charlotte Observer, NC, October 20, 2012

Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools and other area school districts are competing against one another, and hundreds more across the country, for a piece of nearly $400 million in federal Race to the Top grants.

NORTH DAKOTA

Count On Berg For Local Control Of Schools
Grand Fork Herald, ND, October 22, 2012

I appreciate U.S. House candidate Rick Berg’s perspective on education. He has shown his support for high standards, accountability for results, local control and parental choice.

OHIO

Awash in Excellence
Akron Beacon Journal, OH, October 21, 2012

What’s all the grousing about an underperforming public school system in Ohio? Take a look at the latest state report cards, and the impression is that the public is needlessly critical of the quality of public education in Ohio. It appears school districts, by and large, are achieving at or near peak levels.

Schooling Choices Are Beneficial
Cincinnati Enquirer, OH, October 21, 2012

Freedom of choice is a fundamental and vital part of our democracy. As Americans we are free to make choices ranging from our political leaders to what doctor best meets our individual and family needs.

OKLAHOMA

Some Oklahoma Schools Turn To Churches For Help Involving Parents
The Oklahoman, OK, October 22, 2012

They’re mixing church and state in Tulsa schools. That may surprise some in light of Tulsa-area schools’ past hostility to any hint of religious affiliation in learning. Jenks and Union schools sued when state scholarships were given to children with special needs to attend private schools because some had religious affiliations.

PENNSYLVANIA

State Won’t Take Over Vitalistic Charter School
The Morning Call, PA, October 21, 2012

The state Department of Education has rejected a request to take over jurisdiction of the financially troubled Vitalistic Therapeutic Charter School .

Charter School Fight Rages On
Pocono Record, PA, October 21, 2012

The fight between the Pocono Mountain School District and the Pocono Mountain Charter School still burns white hot.

Advocates Fire Back After Charter School Reform Bill Stalls In House
Patriot News, PA, October 22, 2012

For charter school advocates, there’s no truth in the saying “the third time’s the charm.” Not after watching their third effort in a year’s time to get the Legislature to pass a bill that would fix some of the concerns they have with the state’s 1997 charter school law fall apart on Wednesday.

Charter-School Reform – Do It Right
Philadelphia Daily News, PA, October 22, 2012

THE DEATH OF a bad bill is just as noteworthy as the passage of a good one – and let’s face it, both seem to occur with similar frequency.

Better Oversight Still Needed For Charters
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, October 22, 2012

Pennsylvania House members shouldn’t have adjourned without taking up a bill to reform how charter schools operate.

SOUTH CAROLINA

Choices Charter’s Future Up In The Air
Morning News, SC, October 20, 2012

Last-chance school for Florence and Darlington students in limbo after Darlington district cuts its tie

TENNESSEE

Nashville Chamber Wants School Board To Solve Funding Cut Without Legal Fight
The Tennessean, TN, October 22, 2012

Injecting itself squarely into Metro’s ongoing fight with the state over Great Hearts Academies, the Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce is calling for the Metro school board to somehow resolve its loss of $3.4 million in state education funds without pursuing legal action.

Tenn. Needs Statewide Charter School Authorizer
Commercial Appeal, TN, October 20, 2012

Next week, Memphis will host one of the largest — and most important — charter school conferences in the nation: the National Association of Charter School Authorizers (NACSA) Annual Conference, Monday through Thursday at The Peabody.

TEXAS

School Funding Trial Starts Today
Fort Worth Star Telegram, TX, October 21, 2012

As school districts representing more than 3 million Texas schoolchildren go to court today over school funding, they are united on one battlefield but are fighting from multiple fronts

WASHINGTON

Enrollment, Finances Create Challenges For Charter Schools
The Olympian, WA, October 21, 2012

September enrollment at Leadership and Entrepreneurship Public (LEP) Charter High School is down from 344 students at the start of the school year last September to 280 this year. No one is sure why.

Oregon Example: Charters ‘Part Of Fabric’ Of School System
The Olympian, WA, October 21, 2012

As Washington voters prepare to vote on charter schools again, advocates in Oregon wonder why their neighbors to the north are taking so long to see the merits of charters.

Education The Key Issue In Mcauliffe, McCravey Contest
Everett Herald, WA, October 22, 2012

Political stakes are high in the duel between Democratic Sen. Rosemary McAuliffe and Republican Dawn McCravey as the outcome could alter the state’s direction on education policy and the balance of power in the Senate.

Approve Initiative 1240 To Allow Public Charter Schools
Seattle Times, WA, October 21, 2012

If we stand to gain a few outstanding charter schools in Washington state, Initiative 1240 is worth approving, writes guest columnist Katie Baird.

Initiative 1240: Charting A New Course In Washington?
The Olympian, WA, October 21, 2012

I-1240: Charter school backers say they re-energize learning; foes say they benefit few and don’t have good record

ONLINE SCHOOLS

Two Funds Raise Money To Help Bay Area Schools
Contra Costa Times, CA, October 21, 2012

The Silicon Schools Fund has raised half its $25 million goal to create up to 25 technology-heavy schools in the Bay Area within five years. The schools, which could be startups or transformed campuses, would feature “blended learning,” combining traditional classrooms with computer-delivered lessons.

Virtual Academy Educates In Real Life
The Daily Tribune, News, GA, October 20, 2012

Since spring semester 2012, the Bartow Virtual Academy has provided a free virtual learning environment for 32 students in the county who, for a myriad of different reasons, take high school courses online.

8 More Cyber Charter Schools Apply To Pennsylvania
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, October 22, 2012

With 16 full-time cyber charter schools, Pennsylvania already has one of the highest concentrations of such schools in the nation, but now the state has received applications for eight more for the 2013-14 school year.

Christiana Unhappy Charter/Cyber Reform Has Stalled
Beaver Times, PA, October 20, 2012

While many state legislators believe charter and cyber charter school funding must be remedied, the House of Representatives has prevented reform from advancing, according to Rep. Jim Christiana, R-15, Beaver.

DPI Planning ‘In-Depth’ Study Of Virtual Schools
Herald Times Reporter, WI, October 20, 2012

The Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction plans to conduct an “in-depth review” of Wisconsin virtual schools during the 2012-13 school year, fulfilling a recommendation made two and a half years ago following a nonpartisan audit.

Virtual School Enrollment Up 38%
Wausau Daily Herald, WI, October 21, 2012

Enrollment in Wisconsin’s virtual schools soared 38 percent this year, boosted by changes to state law that removed an enrollment cap and substantially expanded the time students have to sign up.

Desert Trails Gets Charter

“LaVerne Prep wins by landslide”
by Lynnea Lombardo
Victorville Daily Press
October 19, 2012

LaVerne Preparatory Academy will be the charter school transforming Desert Trails Elementary, winning the parent vote by a landslide late Thursday night, drawing cheers and hugs from the small crowd of parents and children gathered just outside the school.

The small group of Parent Revolution workers, Desert Trails Parent Union parents and children was disbanded quickly, however, as rumors of a bomb threat circled within the crowd, sending everyone back to the Desert Trails Parent Union headquarters a few blocks away.

The threat came as no surprise to Joe Morales, a DTPU member and founder of HD Dads for Education.

“We’ve experienced opposition from the very beginning,” Morales said. “But we are victorious once again.”

LaVerne Prep in Hesperia, which serves mainly minority students, had the highest API score for charter schools in the High Desert and the highest API score in the entire Hesperia Unified School District.

“The parents made the right choice. We are going to roll up our sleeves and get to work,” said Debra Tarver, founder and executive director of LaVerne Prep, via speaker phone at the DTPU headquarters house. “Our job is the kids. We are ready to go there and do whatever it takes to get things the way they need to be.”

According to a press release from Parent Revolution, this is the first time in the United States that parents, using the Parent Trigger law, have had a direct say in who should run their failing school. For the Parent Trigger law to take effect, more than 50 percent of parents with children attending the school had to sign a petition in favor of comprehensive changes they would like to see made. The Adelanto School District Board of Trustees attempted to rescind 97 signatures of parents who claim they were misled and did not want Desert Trails to be turned into a charter. Victorville Superior Court Judge Steve Malone, however, ruled the recisions could be counted toward the total number, maintaining the 50 percent rule.

Voting was only open to those who signed the petition, even if their children left to attend other schools, said Morales, who said he had been helping with the voting since 4:30 a.m. Thursday.

DTPU originally received four proposals; however, one was rejected because it was a for-profit operator and another operator did not move forward with its proposal, according to a press release from Parent Revolution. The two remaining charter school proposals were from the Lewis Academy of Academic Excellence and LaVerne Prep. Both schools boasted high API scores and smaller than average class sizes.

If all goes smoothly for the Parent Union, LaVerne Prep is set to be fully implemented in time for the 2013-14 school year. The district has 60 days to review the charter school proposal and if the district denies it, Doreen Diaz, lead DTPU organizer, said they will appeal and take the issue to the state if need be.

“We’re hoping the district will follow through and approve it,” Diaz said. “We were supported by two judges’ orders and parents really have negotiating power.”

Alfonso Flores, lead organizer for Parent Revolution and DTPU, said Parent Revolution will be helping DTPU and LaVerne Prep through the transition.

“We are excited that we have gotten this far,” Flores said. “But this is where the real work begins.”

One Last Chance…

by Jeanne Allen
October 19, 2012

Soon the presidential candidates will meet for the last time to debate and with the topic focused on foreign policy, one may be tempted to think education has no place in the discussion. But one would be wrong. There are at least two critical education questions that should be addressed.

QUESTION 1: A recent report from former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and former Chancellor of New York city schools Joel Klein found that “Educational failure puts the United States’ future economic prosperity, global position, and physical safety at risk.” The task force behind the report argued that too many young people are not qualified for the military because they do not have an adequate level of education. Do you agree with them and how would you address the issue?

QUESTION 2: Condoleezza Rice recently told a gathering of education leaders at Education Nation last month that a child in Korea learns in 3rd grade what our kids learn in 5th grade. We know that U.S. students rank 25th out of 34 on math scores among Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries, with nearly one-quarter of U.S. students unable solve the easiest level of questions. Does this lack of international competitiveness concern you and what would your Administration do to address it?

In the previous two debates, President Obama and Governor Romney have talked about education in many contexts: economic, achievement, school choice, and the role of the federal government among others. In this final debate, they have one last chance to inform voters about their vision for education in the country.

###

For more on where Romney and Obama camps stand on critical education issues, head over to our Education and the Presidential Candidates page.

Daily Headlines for October 19, 2012

Rising Charter School Enrollment Seen As Challenge For Catholic Schools
Catholic News Service, October 18, 2012

For the first time, more children are enrolled in charter schools than in Catholic schools, reported the Lexington Institute, a think tank in Arlington , Va. , that focuses on the role of federal government in education reform, tax reform and national security.

FROM THE STATES

CALIFORNIA

Laverne Prep Wins By Landslide
Victorville Daily Press, CA, October 19, 2012

LaVerne Preparatory Academy will be the charter school transforming Desert Trails Elementary, winning the parent vote by a landslide late Thursday night, drawing cheers and hugs from the small crowd of parents and children gathered just outside the school.

Gates Foundation-Funded Education-Reform Group To Close
Los Angeles Times, CA, October 19, 2012

Communities for Teaching Excellence, the national organization based in L.A. , plans to close next month after its board voted to shutter it and the Gates philanthropy ended financial support.

Once Failing Highland Park School Making Strides
Bell Gardens Sun, CA, October 18, 2012

School officials last week held a ribbon cutting ceremony to celebrate the opening of three new buildings on the Northeast Los Angeles area campus. The event happened to coincide with the release of the state’s Academic Performance Index (API) reports that showed Burbank had increased its score by 100 points, far above the average increase across the district and the state.

Landmark California School Law Wins Key Court Ruling
Modesto Bee, CA, October 19, 2012

The Adelanto case, and Romero’s role, also underscore one very intriguing political development – a divide between the education establishment, including the powerful California Teachers Association, and some Democratic political figures, such as Romero, who see poor schools as a civil rights issue.

Big Money In Play In Oakland School Board Campaigns
Oakland Tribune, CA, October 18, 2012

Local school board races are often low-budget, low-profile affairs, and until now, Oakland has been no exception. But this year, two new political action committees have thrown themselves into the election, infusing once-lethargic races with energy — and cash.

COLORADO

School Choices Grew Out Of Community Desires, Changed Laws
North Denver Tribune, CO, October 18, 2012

Education discussion in NW continues to brew, and with greater frequency, boil. The neighborhood gentrification, which picked up speed in the late 1990s, brings a wave of kids and their educated middle-class parents who seek improvement in the quality and choices of schools.

New Tool Helps Families Match Students To Schools
9NEWS, CO, October 18, 2012

Colorado is one of the few states nationwide to offer the “open-enrollment” form of public-school choice. Open enrollment allows students to attend any school they choose to, regardless of where they live, provided the school has space.

DELAWARE

Capital School District Followed State Law In Dealing With Academy Of Dover, Superintendent Says
Dover Post, DE, October 18, 2012

Capital School District Superintendent Michael Thomas said Wednesday night that building principals followed state law when it came to dealing with students who showed up at their doors despite dual enrollment at a charter school.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

D.C. Losing De’Shawn Wright, Deputy Mayor For Education
Washington Post, DC, October 18, 2012

De’Shawn Wright, the D.C. deputy mayor for education, who has played a key role in decision making about the future of the city’s public schools, is leaving his post for a job in New York state, Mayor Vincent C. Gray (D) announced Thursday.

District Suit Alleges Woman Lived In Md. , Sent Daughter To D.C. School
Washington Post, DC, October 18, 2012

D.C. officials have filed a civil suit against the mother of a teenager who allegedly lived in Maryland while attending D.C. public schools for free, Attorney General Irvin B. Nathan announced Thursday.

FLORIDA

Clay School Board Gives Proposed Charter School More Time
Florida Times Union, FL, October 19, 2012

The Clay County School Board will waive its own policy to give a proposed performing arts charter school extra time to provide additional information proving it will meet state standards.

GEORGIA

Chair Denies Improper Act On Charter Vote
Marietta Daily Journal, GA, October 19, 2012

Lithia Springs activist James Bell filed a complaint with the state attorney general last week alleging the Douglas County Board of Education and Superintendent Gordon Pritz acted improperly by using public resources to take a public stand on a ballot question.

Charter Battle Not Just Politics
Cherokee Tribune, GA, October 19, 2012

For those who have been following the debate regarding Amendment One — the Charter Amendment — and wondering why everyone is so upset, I wanted to give you some final thoughts. For those of us in the thick of it, it’s a passionate subject that goes to the basic instinct of parents, what’s best for our kids and who is best to decide that.

GEORGIA

Gwinnett Education Officials: Public Schools Have Improved
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, October 18, 2012

Having been warned about lobbying against the charter school amendment on taxpayer time, Gwinnett school officials are trying a new tact: touting the success of the state’s public schools.

INDIANA

More Kids Using Vouchers to Attend Private Schools
WIBC, IN, October 18, 2012

Alex Damron with the Department of Education says more than 9,000 students took advantage of the “Choice Scholarships” this school year. Students are eligible for a voucher if they meet certain income requirements, regardless of whether their public school is failing by the department’s standards.

Don’t Put Private Sector Before Public Education
Indianapolis Star, IN, October 18, 2012

As a retired classroom teacher with 30 years’ experience, I am concerned with the direction public education seems to be headed in Indiana . A free public education is one of the principles on which our country has been based, but the interests of the for-profit world seem to be impinging more and more into the classroom.

LOUISIANA

Superintendent Raps 4 School Systems
The Advocate, LA, October 19, 2012

School systems in St. Martin and three other parishes have failed to comply with a state law that bans the use of seniority in teacher layoff decisions, state Superintendent of Education John White said Thursday.

Option Proposed For Review Holes
The Advocate, LA, October 19, 2012

Public school teachers who get poor evaluations even though their students scored well could get special consideration, state Superintendent of Education John White said Thursday.

MISSISSIPPI

Parents Could Seek Charters At 35 Miss. Schools
WSLS, MS, October 18, 2012

Maybe you saw it on the big screen in “Won’t Back Down.” Parent takeovers of failing public schools could be coming to Mississippi .

MISSOURI

New Charter Schools Opening In St. Louis For 2013 School Year
KSDK, MO, October 18, 2012

Three new public charter schools will open in the City of St. Louis beginning next school year, Mayor Francis Slay said Thursday.

With Vote Looming, Support Endures For Student Transfer Program
St. Louis Post-Dispatch, MO, October 19, 2012

When a class at Clayton High set out to study race at its school, students inevitably touched on the effectiveness of the region’s voluntary transfer program.

MARYLAND

Teachers Should Know How They Are Graded
Maryland Impendent, MD, October 19, 2012

The Calvert County Board of Education last week announced three additional early dismissal days would be added to the school calendar next year in order to allow teachers extra time to learn how they would be evaluated under the new federal Race to the Top guidelines.

NEW JERSEY

Newark Teachers Contract, a Game-Changer for NJ’s Often-Troubled School District
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, October 19, 2012

Pay for performance and peer reviews are radical changes — but they also show what can be done with $50 million in private funding

NEW MEXICO

APS Seeking Race to the Top Grant
Albuquerque Journal, NM, October 19, 2012

Albuquerque Public Schools is throwing its hat in the ring for a federal Race to the Top grant that could bring in up to $40 million in extra funding.

NEW YORK

Shameful Attack
New York Post, NY, October 19, 2012

I’ve been teaching in New York City public schools for six years — three in a traditional district school, and three at a Success Academy charter school. During this time, I’ve witnessed the annual protest brigade against Success public schools, and I thought I’d seen it all. But charter opponents took their extreme tactics to a new low last week.

PENNSYLVANIA

West Mifflin Area School Director: Give Us Charter School Pay Rate
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, October 19, 2012

West Mifflin Area school director Phil Shar wants his district to sue the state Department of Education, claiming the district is owed hundreds of thousands of dollars for educating Duquesne students over the past five years.

Pa. House Skips Vote On Charter-School Bill
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, October 19, 2012

The clock ran out on the Pennsylvania General Assembly’s two-year legislative session Wednesday with a big surprise: It failed to pass changes in charter-school law that had been supported by the Corbett administration and the Senate and House leadership.

House Failure To Pass Charter School Bill Disappoints York County Lawmakers
York Dispatch, PA, October 18, 2012

Frustration lingers for some York County lawmakers and educators after a charter school bill that would have addressed their concerns about funding and accountability died in the House.

TENNESSEE

Metro School Board To Weigh Legal Options Over Great Hearts
The Tennessean, TN, October 19, 2012

The Metro school board has apparently split from city attorneys in its rift with the state over Great Hearts Academies as board members weigh their next move after the state’s decision to withhold education funds.

Nashville Festival Lets Parents Learn School Choices
The Tennessean, TN, October 19, 2012

Parents began showing up as soon as Metro schools’ First School Choice Festival began Thursday afternoon and continued arriving into the night, with an estimated 1,000 people there at any one time.

TEXAS

Candidates Discuss Education Vouchers During Debate
Victoria Advocate, TX, October 18, 2012

Texas educators are opposed to issuing private school vouchers, Alex Hernandez Jr. said, and that’s why he is, too. His opponent, Rep. Geanie Morrison, however, said it was too soon to decide.

UTAH

Union Leaders Urge Teachers To Fight For What’s Right
Salt Lake Tribune, UT, October 18, 2012

Utah teachers must continue to fight. It was a message state and national teachers union leaders shared with those who attended the Utah Education Association’s (UEA) annual convention Thursday, an event that often attracts between 3,000 and 4,000 people.

WASHINGTON

Education Reform Opposition Slams Propositions
Spokesman Review, WA, October 19, 2012

The latest campaign commercial from opponents of Idaho’s education reform ballot measures focuses on Proposition 2, the teacher merit-pay measure, suggesting that Idaho ’s schools superintendent wants to “treat children like widgets.”

Separating Education From Creating Schools
Kitsap Sun, WA, October 18, 2012

It’s time for Washington State to join 42 other jurisdictions in expanding educational opportunities for our children. Please support the creation of charter public schools and vote Yes on I-1240.

‘Yes’ on I-1240, Charter Schools
Bellevue Reporter, WA, October 18, 2012

Few things are more important than education. Our children’s’ futures – and ours, too – hangs in the balance.

WYOMING

Committee Shapes Wyoming Teacher Evaluation System
Casper Star-Tribune, WY, October 19, 2012

A statewide system of evaluating teachers should have a balance of local and state control, according to an advisory committee to the Wyoming Legislature working to develop a framework for educator evaluations.

ONLINE SCHOOLS

Cumberland Valley Allows Cyber Charter School Students To Join Extracurricular Activities
Patriot News, PA, October 18, 2012

Cyber charter school students can now participate in extracurricular activities and interscholastic athletic programs in the Cumberland Valley School District .

DPI Planning ‘In-Depth’ Study of Virtual Schools
Fond du Lac Reporter, WI, October 18, 2012

The Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction plans to conduct an “in-depth review” of Wisconsin virtual schools during the 2012-13 school year, fulfilling a recommendation made two and a half years ago following a nonpartisan audit.