Sign up for our newsletter

Statement on Closure of D.C. Public Schools

Another Example of Charter Schools Not Receiving Equal Operational Dollars and Equity in Facilities

CER Press Release
Washington, D.C.
November 14, 2012

Center for Education Reform Founder and President Jeanne Allen made the following statement regarding the announcement that D.C. Public Schools proposes closing 19 facilities, and not giving the buildings a surplus designation.

“The Chancellor of D.C. Public Schools has gotten a pass from reformers because of her work on teacher evaluations, and for being tough on failure. But even in these she has shown herself more interested in fixing a system than boosting solutions – like charters – that will give children access to any good alternative. In this latest move, she is effectively sitting on buildings that belong to the public, not to the system. It provides yet another example of charter schools in D.C. not receiving equal operational dollars and equity when it comes to facilities, despite a law that explicitly says they should. Equity demands that all public school children share in the pie.

“Ms. Henderson has made it clear that she wants more control over charter schools. In this, the Council, which supports her, is not engaged in fighting for real justice for kids. Whereas the Mayor, the Council, the business community and parents once stood resolved that choice through charters would be an essential element of education in D.C., today they operate to preserve their power, not parent power.

“The recent school closure announcement should have fused the districts corrective action with expanded opportunity for kids. Instead the issues are divided, and so are our leaders.

“I urge the media to look closely at this incident and how it reveals a chasm between the Chancellor and the Council’s rhetoric and their actions. It’s time the Chancellor was asked to account for her unequal treatment of the public good.”

Daily Headlines for November 14, 2012

Enrollment in Charter Schools Is Increasing
New York Times, NY, November 14, 2012

Although charter schools engender fierce debate — most recently over ballot measures in Georgia and Washington State — their ranks are growing rapidly, according to a new report. Between 2010-11 and 2011-12, the number of students in charter schools increased close to 13 percent, to just over two million.

FROM THE STATES

ALABAMA

Ala. Governor Won’t Try Charter Schools Again
Times-Journal, AL, November 13, 2012

Gov. Robert Bentley says he doesn’t plan to propose the legalization of charter schools again in the 2013 session of the Legislature.

ARIZONA

Charter Schools Transforming Arizona’s Education Landscape
East Valley Tribune, AZ, November 13, 2012

When the Goldwater Institute recently recruited attorney candidates from out of state, I was able to use a lure I never would have thought possible: Arizona has the best public schools in the country.

CALIFORNIA

LAUSD Rejects Voluntary Moratorium On New Charter Schools
Contra Costa Times, CA, November 13, 2012

Following a flood of protests from parents and charter supporters, the Los Angeles Unified board on Tuesday soundly rejected a resolution seeking a voluntary moratorium on new charter applications while a strategic plan is developed to better govern their explosive growth.

LAUSD Restores Full Academic Year And Full Pay
Los Angeles Times, CA, November 14, 2012

The actions were made possible by passage of Proposition 30. Members also approve a resolution to charge fees when charters claim more space on traditional campuses than they need.

Parents, Administrators Rally In Support Of Charter Schools
Los Angeles Times Blog, CA, November 13, 2012

About 1,000 parents and administrators from charter schools flooded Beaudry Avenue in front of Los Angeles Unified School District headquarters on Tuesday in opposition to a motion the school board was to consider at its meeting inside.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

Henderson Announces Plan To Close 20 D.C. Schools
Washington Times, DC, November 13, 2012

D.C. Public Schools Chancellor Kaya Henderson on Tuesday announced 20 schools that could be closed next year, among them the alma mater of four former NBA players, the District’s first junior high school and an educational center built in 1927.

D.C. Teacher Turnover Is Astronomical
Letter Washington Post, DC, November 13, 2012

The Nov. 10 editorial “Passing a test,” about a study of the effect of D.C. school reforms, neglected to point out that the New Teacher Project, author of the study, was founded by former D.C. schools chancellor Michelle Rhee and is under contract with the D.C. Public Schools (DCPS) to provide teacher recruits. It is hardly a disinterested party.

FLORIDA

For Pinellas Teachers Upset About Evaluations, Superintendent Writes Letter Of Explanation
Tampa Bay Times, FL, November 14, 2012

For the many Pinellas schoolteachers who got less-than-perfect evaluations this year, superintendent Mike Grego plans to write a letter admitting the evaluation system itself was, well, less than perfect.

Charter School Fund Drive Nears $2 Million
News Chief, FL, November 14, 2012

Just four months into a fundraising campaign, Lake Wales Charter Schools has raised nearly $2 million.

GEORGIA

Greenville Ga. Superintendent Barge Launches Branding Campaign
Jackson Progress Argus, GA, November 14, 2012

Georgians often bemoan the quality of their public schools. But state Superintendent John Barge, fresh off a defeat in a debate over expanding charter schools, wants to change public perception.

All In For Openness, Accountability
Cherokee Ledger News, GA, November 14, 2012

As we closed out the election last week, Cherokee County and state voters spoke, and Amendment 1 passed, allowing a third entity that can approve charter schools.

Voters Deliver Blow To Charter Opposition
Newton Citizen, GA, November 13, 2012

In the crossfire of vitriol igniting the charter school debate allies and foes faced off, education officials and legislators parted ideological ways, and school boards approved and published anti-charter resolutions only to have removal forced upon them by the state attorney general.

IDAHO

Teachers to Get Merit Pay by Dec. 15
Twin Falls Times-New, ID, November 14, 2012

Even though voters overturned the Students Come First laws, teachers who earned merit pay during the last school year can expect a payment by Dec. 15.

Charter School Proposed For Blaine County
Idaho Mountain Express, ID, November 13, 2012

A group of parents and supporters of the private Mountain School near Bellevue, which minimizes technology in the classroom and focuses on academic rigor and sustainable living, is seeking to establish a public charter school in Blaine County.

ILLINOIS

‘I Want To Go To School’
Chicago Tribune, IL, November 14, 2012

Tribune reporters Gary Marx, David Jackson and Alex Richards found that nearly 32,000 Chicago students in public elementary schools — roughly 1 in 8 students — missed four weeks or more of class during the 2010-11 year.

MICHIGAN

Strengthen Reform Program For Schools
Detroit News, MI, November 14, 2012

A year and a half ago, Gov. Rick Snyder announced the creation of the Education Achievement Authority. He envisioned it as a new school district that would bring the worst-performing schools in the state into its fold. The authority began as an inter-local agreement between Eastern Michigan University and Detroit Public Schools , but now it’s time to place the reform district into law.

Detroit Public Schools Board Votes To Cut Ties To Educational Authority
Detroit News, MI, November 14, 2012

A week after voters overturned Public Act 4, the Detroit Board of Education voted Tuesday night to break the district’s contract with Eastern Michigan University and withdraw from the Education Achievement Authority.

Michigan Attorney General’s Office Seeks To Remove 7 DPS Board Members
Detroit News, MI, November 14, 2012

The Michigan Attorney General’s Office is seeking the removal of seven members of the Detroit Board of Education, accusing the members of illegally holding office because they were elected by district.

NEW HAMPSHIRE

Exeter Charter School’s Goal Is To Make Everyone A Grad
Union Leader, NH, November 13, 2012

Seven years ago, the Great Bay Charter School was founded to address the growing need to provide alternatives for students who were not succeeding in a traditional high school setting.

NEW JERSEY

Department of Education Cheating Investigation Implicates Two More Schools
New Jersey Spotlight, NJ, November 14, 2012

Report claims that improvements in test scores at Robert Treat Academy, a high-profile charter, defy all odds

NEW MEXICO

Funding Suggestions Try To Address Students’ Achievement Gap
Albuquerque Journal, NM, November 14, 2012

A task force looking to improve the way New Mexico distributes education funding is recommending more money for low-income students, changes to charter school funding, and district funding that is linked to the three-tier teacher licensure system.

NEW YORK

Few Parents Attend Meeting On Charter School Plan
Buffalo News, NY, November 14, 2012

A few parents from Waterfront Elementary School were among the dozen or so people who attended an informational session Tuesday evening about a proposal to turn Waterfront and East High into charter schools.

NORTH CAROLINA

New Wake Assignment Plan Draws Board Praise
News & Observer, NC, November 14, 2012

After years of bitter debate over where children will go to school in Wake County, school board members welcomed a new plan Tuesday that will move fewer than 1,500 students to different schools next year.

OHIO

Good Adviser
Columbus Dispatch, OH, November 14, 2012

The search for a new superintendent for Columbus City Schools should benefit substantially from the steady hand and sincere concern of Mayor Michael B. Coleman, who is joining the effort as part of his recent outreach to the school district.

Volunteer Group’s Support Of Parents At Warner Girls Leadership Academy Is Model For School
Cleveland Plain Dealer, OH, November 13, 2012

Three years ago, every Cleveland school had a paid staffer who worked to build parent and community involvement. But those positions were among the first to be axed when the school district slashed its budget during the early recession years.

PENNSYLVANIA

School Revamp Plan Is Detailed
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, November 14, 2012

After years of decline, Chester Upland would close buildings and shed staff under Pa. proposal.

West Easton Fine-Tunes Zoning For Charter School
The Morning Call, PA, November 13, 2012

West Easton Borough Council fine-tuned a new zoning law Monday when it approved several additional conditions to the measure that will allow a charter school to open in what will be a renovated warehouse.

Tough Fiscal Choices Ahead For Pittsburgh Public Schools
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, November 14, 2012

About 10 years ago, Pittsburgh Public Schools had a fund balance approaching $100 million.
Now — despite closing more than 30 schools, eliminating hundreds of jobs and increasing class sizes — officials have forecast the district will be broke in 2015 unless it finds a way to further cut costs or increase revenues.

SOUTH CAROLINA

Legacy Charter Leading The Way In Changing Role Of Physical Education In Schools
Greenville News, SC, November 14, 2012

There are no vending machines at Legacy Charter School. The cafeteria doesn’t serve fried foods, and the new fitness center has a collegiate feel with its rows of bikes, treadmills and weight machines. There’s even a room for Zumba off to the side, where parents and faculty can sign up for free classes.

TENNESSEE

School Vouchers Task Force Unspecific on Cost, Scope
Nashville Public Radio, TN, November 13, 2012

The governor’s task force on school vouchers says they should focus on students from poor families. But a draft report from the group stops short of pinning down some tough details. Next year lawmakers will likely take up vouchers, which would divert money out of public schools, so parents could instead pay private school tuition.

Smithson-Craighead Middle School Will Close; Great Hearts Charter Gets Another Look
The Tennessean, TN, November 14, 2012

The Metro Nashville school board on Tuesday decided to close one charter school and offered an olive branch to another, Great Hearts Academies, which was denied a charter in West Nashville three times earlier this year.

School Vouchers Raise Big Issues, Need Close Study; Harwell Says
Marshall County Tribune, TN, November 14, 2012

School vouchers raise tough constitutional questions, Tennessee House Speaker Beth Harwell says, acknowledging America ‘s standard of equal treatment under the law.

TEXAS

Simpson Tells Longview ISD Trustees That He Doesn’t Support School Vouchers
Longview News-Journal, TX, November 14, 2012

Longview’s state lawmaker said Tuesday that he is not in favor of a voucher system for public schools.

VIRGINIA

Virginia’s Race-Based Education
Washington Times, DC, November 13, 2012

Nearly five decades after the end of the Jim Crow era, school boards just can’t let go of the race issue. Last month, the Virginia State Board of Education unanimously adopted what it called “annual measurable objectives” that assumed the graduation rate for Asian children would be 14-37 percent higher than whites, Hispanics and blacks. The bureaucracy’s obsession with skin color distracts teachers from doing their job.

VERMONT

A Tough Choice In North Bennington
Bennington Banner, VT, November 14, 2012

The closeness of the recent vote in favor of closing North Bennington Graded School and creating an independent school, and now a pending third vote forced by submission of a citizen petition — along with other factors surrounding this divisive issue — have darkly clouded what seemed a sure thing just a few short months ago.

WASHINGTON

Ill-Fated Teacher Bonuses Patchy
Spokesman Review, WA, November 14, 2012

Idaho on Tuesday revealed which schools made the cut under a pay-for-performance system rejected by voters a week earlier.

Charter Schools Coming To State, Probably Not To Cowlitz County
Longview Daily News, WA, November 13, 2012

Initiative 1240 sustained its narrow lead Tuesday afternoon, making Washington the 42nd state to approve charter schools — although it’s unlikely any will come to Cowlitz County .

The Charter-School Poison Pill
Seattle Weekly, WA, November 13, 2012

If the charter-school initiative, I-1240, passes—which is all but a sure thing now, though opponents hadn’t conceded by press time—schools activist and blogger Melissa Westbrook worries about what she calls the measure’s “poison pill.” That’s the clause that allows for an existing public school to convert to a charter.

State Schools Chief May File Suit Against Creation Of Charter Schools
Q13 Fox News, WA, November 13, 2012

A day after the charter schools initiative was declared a winner by a small margin, Washington’s superintendent of public instruction went on the offensive.

Onward With Charter Schools
The Columbian, WA, November 13, 2012

The most closely contested of Washington’s four ballot measures has been decided. Fortunately for students, parents, teachers and taxpayers, the state will join 41 other states that offer public charter schools. Initiative 1240 was passed with 50.8 percent approval on Monday afternoon.

WYOMING

Wyoming Education Reform May Take Longer
Laramie Boomerang, WY, November 14, 2012

Wyoming’s effort to make its public school students better prepared for college and careers may take up to two years longer to fully implement, members of the Wyoming Board of Education said.

ONLINE SCHOOLS

CYBER-CHARTERS: How Districts Are Luring Cyber Students Back
Lancaster News Era, PA, November 13, 2012

Trouble with other students led Jonathan Kennedy to leave middle school and enroll in a cyber-charter program.

CYBER-CHARTERS: Legislature Fails To Bring Cyber-Charters Into Line
Lancaster News Era, PA, November 14, 2012

Two students from Lancaster County school districts attend the same cyber-charter school. The teachers, textbooks, curriculum and computers are the same. Only the tuition is different: One student’s bill is more than $2,000 higher.

Georgia Cyber Academy Assailed For Missing Special Ed Requirements
Atlanta Journal-Constitution, GA, November 13, 2012

State Board of Education members blasted Georgia Cyber Academy officials Tuesday, saying the online school is failing to meet the needs of its special education students.

Georgia Connections Academy 1st Virtual School To Participate In Georgia’s Apply To College Day
WJBF, GA, November 13, 2012

On November 15th, Georgia Connections Academy , a k-12 public virtual charter school, will become the state’s first online school to participate in Georgia ’s Apply to College Day.

St. Martin Virtual School
KLFY, LA, November 13, 2012

More and more students are enrolled in Saint Martin Parish’s Virtual Learning program. The program was launched this summer with just 15 students enrolled. But now, it has over 140 students.

Online Students Lag State Averages
Education News Colorado, CO, November 13, 2012

Two new studies point to a contradiction about full-time online schools – student academic performance is lower than that of students statewide but parents and students are positive about the online experience.

Charter School Credit To Be Limited
Albuquerque Journal, NM, November 14, 2012

Albuquerque Public Schools students seeking to take online classes from a charter school or other organization will soon find it harder to do so.

Los Angeles Charter Moratorium Rejected

“LAUSD rejects voluntary moratorium on new charter schools”
by Barbara Jones
Contra Costa Times
November 13, 2012

Following a flood of protests from parents and charter supporters, the Los Angeles Unified board on Tuesday soundly rejected a resolution seeking a voluntary moratorium on new charter applications while a strategic plan is developed to better govern their explosive growth.

Board member Steve Zimmer said he saw the need for an in-depth study of the district’s charter system, which now educates some 110,000 students and has thousands more on waiting lists. He wanted to monitor how well charter schools are educating students and ways to share methods for closing the achievement gap and boosting parental involvement.

“The milestone of 100,000 is a moment in which we should step back and reflect on what is working in our role as (charter) operator and what isn’t,” he said. “We need to have a real strategy and a real plan.”

But parents and charter supporters saw his resolution as a challenge to their right to choose the appropriate school for their child, with speakers sharing personal stories of how charters had changed their lives.

“You shouldn’t just vote against the resolution,” said parent Katrina George, whose handicapped son struggled at a traditional school but thrived once he was enrolled in a charter. “You should do the opposite and open more charters. At the end of the day, this should be about the kids.”

Zimmer’s colleagues said they’d tried to talk him out of pursuing the resolution, and Superintendent John Deasy said it was unnecessary.

“The work can be done without the resolution,” Deasy said.

In the end, Zimmer and board member Bennett Kayser cast the only yes votes for the resolution. Board member Marguerite Poindexter LaMotte had left during the debate and was not present for the vote.

Zimmer’s original resolution, introduced in September, called on the board to postpone or refer new charter applications to the Los Angeles County Office of Education. Critics noted that would be illegal, and he revised the proposal to ask charter operators to voluntarily hold off on submitting new applications until a timetable was in place for the suggested reforms.

Parents signed petitions and as many as 2,000 demonstrators flooded the street in front of LAUSD during a lunchtime protest. Most were gone by the time the board got through a lengthy agenda.

“We’re not the enemy,” said charter pioneer Joe Lucente, repeating comments he made during the demonstration. “Our very existence benefits all students, whether in traditional or charter schools… Don’t fear us, embrace us.”

The board also wrestled with arequest to renew the charter for Gabriella Charter, which shares space with Logan Span School in Echo Park. Parents from both schools – both of them thriving – said there just wasn’t room on the campus to meet the needs of the students.

The board OK’d the extension with the charter, which boasts an arts education program and an API of 894, with the understanding that Deasy will try to find additional space for Gabriella.

Zimmer said it was just this sort of situation – “a collision of goodness” – he wanted to avoid when he introduced his resolution.

“The system has become about competitionand not innovation,” he said.

“I want to know what we can do best when we collaborate.”

Board members Tamar Galatzan and Nury Martinez admonished Zimmer that he could not work around Proposition 39, the voter-approved measure that requires school districts to accommodate space requests from independent charters.

“Ten years ago, voters approved Prop. 39,” Martinez said. “To continue to have these debates when you know what the law is polarizes hundreds of thousands of parents … Be done with it, Mr. Zimmer.”

Letter to LAUSD Board: Updating Charter Authorizing and Oversight

November 13, 2012

Board of Education
Los Angeles Unified School District
333 South Beaudry Avenue, 24th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90017

Dear Members of the Los Angeles Unified School Board:

I am writing you this morning to caution the Los Angeles Unified School Board on a measure that would set the city back over a decade in progress. The Resolution before you today, “Updating Charter Authorizing and Oversight,” proposed by Mr. Zimmer, lacks sound policy and would severely hurt a large population of students in the Los Angeles Unified School District.

The 110,000 students currently being served by charters authorized by LAUSD have not declined enrollment for the district, but rather, are students who have been retained by the district through the creation of options for parents and adding 232 charter schools to the district’s portfolio of educational offerings.

Requiring all charter schools to use the District’s ISIS system by January 1, 2013 is an unreasonable mandate and timeline that goes against the operational autonomy defined by California’s charter school law. It is commonly known that ISIS is a work in progress, full of bugs and lacks the technical support schools need to integrate. Charter schools can and have generated the data LAUSD needs using current structures and internal reporting mechanisms.

There’s also no question that charter schools are meeting performance goals and in most cases, are outperforming conventional district schools. Consider The Accelerated Schools boast a 93 percent four-year graduation rate. Granada Hills Charter High School serves nearly 4,300 students with an in-seat attendance rate of 97.4 percent. GHCHS scored an 878 on the 2012 API and is the only comprehensive high school in Los Angeles with an API above 850. These are just two examples out of 232 charter schools improving outcomes for your students.

In our nearly 20-year experience at the Center, the formation of a Charter Oversight Commission is not a sound policy for the District to adopt. Too often these commissions, while well intentioned, never get the projected results but cost more time and resources and as proposed in the resolution before you, is only a stall tactic to limit options for parents and the portfolio of schools LAUSD is known for offering.

Finally, we strongly urge you to not postpone the review of new charter school applications. There are thousands of parents in Los Angeles still on charter school waiting lists and it is important for this body to continue to explore ways to meet that demand. New charter schools play an important role in the robust charter school movement LAUSD has supported. Halting growth would set the city back at least a decade in progress.

The Center for Education Reform, since 1993, is the leading voice and advocate for lasting, substantive and structural education reform in the U.S. We know the nation looks to a majority of your charter schools as national models of success and both traditional public schools and charters across the country work to emulate these programs. We encourage you to continue to explore ways to share best practices that the charter sector has to offer LAUSD in its own backyard.

Respectfully,
Kara Kerwin
Vice President of External Affairs
 

CLICK HERE for board members’ emails and information about the RALLY TODAY at 11:00am!

Districts Wonder if Race to Top is Worth Cost

by Pauline Liu
Times Herald-Record
November 12, 2012

The federal Race to the Top competition is making school districts dole out far more money than they’re receiving from the program, according to school officials and experts.

For some districts, it’s wreaking havoc.

“Race to the Top has turned the district upside down,” said Monticello School Superintendent Daniel Teplesky. “The teachers are anxious.”

It seems that the program has teachers in Newburgh so anxious that some aired their grievances at a Board of Education meeting recently. “Teachers are depressed, demoralized, and that serves no one, especially not our students,” said teachers association president Art Plichta to the school board.

As for Newburgh Schools Superintendent Ralph Pizzo, he’s blaming mandates, though not specifically RTTT, for soaring costs that have put the district “roughly $10 million above the tax cap.”

In an open letter that he posted online a couple of weeks ago, he expressed concerns about cutting programs and closing a school. He did not return calls for comment.

There are a lot of changes, including a new teacher- and principal-evaluation system, a new curriculum that’s aligned with new learning standards as well as more tests for students and more training for teachers.

The costs of implementing RTTT have been outlined in a new report by Ken Mitchell, a schools superintendent in Rockland County.

He looks at districts in the Lower Hudson and offers hard numbers illustrating the huge disparity been what they actually receive from the program and what they must spend in order to participate in it.

The study was done for SUNY New Paltz’s Center for Research, Regional Education and Outreach and has been posted on its website.

“This is what happens when you have folks running federal and state educational systems, when they have never really been around the systems they are purporting to run,” said Middletown School Superintendent Ken Eastwood, who called the study “dead on.”

Middletown, as well as Monticello, Florida and Wallkill all expect to spend somewhere in the neighborhood of $250,000 this school year in order to meet the requirements of the program.

Some districts, such as Wallkill, will spend as much as nine times what they actually receive. Wallkill’s annual grant is $25,000. Florida’s annual grant is $4,415.

Still, superintendents are not about to pan the program totally.

“We believe the changes being promoted are responsive to the changing world for which we are preparing our students,” said Florida Schools Superintendent Diane Munro.

“While we are deeply concerned about the costs, we see the potential payoff for the investment, and are hopeful that the state will take action on the many other unfunded mandates that drain funds from instructional programs.”

Likewise, Wallkill Schools Superintendent Bill Hecht feels the program is worthwhile.

“I like the Common Core curriculum and the implementation of teacher and principal evaluations,” said Hecht. “My concern is that the timeline is an aggressive timeline that is causing stress on the system.”

While the jury is still out on whether the program will work, administrators are continuing their efforts to put it in place. “Once the bureaucratic setup of it is done, it will have to be reviewed and … it may take the four years to evaluate to see if it’s effective or not,” said Mary-Stephanie Corsones, Kingston’s assistant superintendent for curriculum.

Missed Opportunity: Education Reform Could’ve Been Winning Issue

So where was the issue of education reform during the presidential campaign? Republicans didn’t even visit the cities that owe their education salvation to this leadership. While strong reformers who are Republicans continue to run and win elections in states, Republicans at the national level seem not to understand that in supporting educational choice they are supporting a civil right, and that they are the leaders in this support. Republican embrace of individual freedom and liberties over government at the local, state and federal level is an anchor for education reform. And it is repulsive to those who manage and protect the status quo.

Tuesday’s results are not the only wake-up call. Here’s another one: Democrats are working hard to own this issue. Do they deserve the credit? Will they advance the movement? No, but President Obama and his party have vowed to make their party the party of education reform. A recent missive from the Democrats for Education Reform declared Obama “EdReformer in Chief.” He has done little to merit such a title.

We’ve praised Obama’s candor and vocalization of the problems facing American education. We’ve commended the power his Education secretary has wielded to talk about issues that most reformers embrace. But his Administration is conspicuously quiet on the issue of real school choice. And while they talk about ensuring real performance pay for teachers, underneath the talk, the teachers unions are still in charge.

Think about the Democratic Party and this bedrock constituency. Unions once helped those most in need, but today they are keeping those poorest children, those who cannot afford to change zip codes or pay tuition to escape, in failing schools.

President Obama and his majority at the national level continue to oppose attempts to give those students choices. Absent leadership, the nation sits quietly as we shutter hundreds of exceptional Catholic schools that have educated Black and Latino communities, and that educated the Greatest Generation prior to them.

And what were we treated to this election cycle? While Romney’s platform supported parents and students over union prerogatives, neither candidate ran on the issue of ensuring children are educated by whatever means necessary. It almost seems it’s not politically correct to acknowledge that Republicans do something about education reform, while Democrats are forced to negotiate with their supporters, always to reduced effect.

So now what? READ MORE

Education Reform Could Have Been A Winning Issue

by Jeanne Allen
Politico
November 10, 2012

The question of the week seems to be, how can the GOP appeal to a wider variety of Americans? Here’s an idea: They can boast more about their leadership on education reform.

Education reform is and has always been a bipartisan issue. But while the movement numbers a handful of Democrats among its truly committed, it was built on the intellectual energy of conservatives, and has been propelled by the energy, for the most part, of Republican elected officials. Success in making fundamental changes to educate poor and minority children and strengthening the quality of education for all kids has been, and continues to be, primarily a Republican achievement.

It is positive that many people in the myriad and growing number of education reform groups and foundations have differing political views. But it was, and continues to be, Republicans who shattered the common myths that have stymied reform. For decades, these myths – about class sizes mattering, about teacher tenure being critical for success, about money being the answer, to name a few – had been propped up by traditional civil rights and child-centered organizations.

Republicans challenged the education establishment to account for decades of failure and started talking about providing alternatives, and about closing failing public schools. The initial impetus – the first ideas and first law for charter schools – were from liberal academics and a liberal Minnesota. But it was conservatives who took up the banner and provided the leadership that led to the best charter school laws in the most populous states. It was Republican governors who found common ground with African-American democrats to bring about publicly funded scholarships for kids – vouchers – in Milwaukee and Cleveland, a trend followed in fourteen states.

Some Democratic state legislators bolstered the work of their Republican Governors. But one wouldn’t have happened without the other.

So where was this issue during the presidential campaign? Republicans didn’t even visit the cities that owe their education salvation to this leadership. While strong reformers who are Republicans continue to run and win elections in states, Republicans at the national level seem not to understand that in supporting educational choice they are supporting a civil right, and that they are the leaders in this support. Republican embrace of individual freedom and liberties over government at the local, state and federal level is an anchor for education reform. And it is repulsive to those who manage and protect the status quo.

Tuesday’s results are not the only wake-up call. Here’s another one: Democrats are working hard to own this issue. Do they deserve the credit? Will they advance the movement? No, but President Obama and his party have vowed to make their party the party of education reform. A recent missive from the Democrats for Education Reform declared Obama “EdReformer in Chief.” He has done little to merit such a title.

We’ve praised Obama’s candor and vocalization of the problems facing American education. We’ve commended the power his Education secretary has wielded to talk about issues that most reformers embrace. But his Administration is conspicuously quiet on the issue of real school choice. And while they talk about ensuring real performance pay for teachers, underneath the talk, the teachers unions are still in charge.

Think about the Democratic Party and this bedrock constituency. Unions once helped those most in need, but today they are keeping those poorest children, those who cannot afford to change zip codes or pay tuition to escape, in failing schools.

President Obama and his majority at the national level continue to oppose attempts to give those students choices. Absent leadership, the nation sits quietly as we shutter hundreds of exceptional Catholic schools that have educated Black and Latino communities, and that educated the Greatest Generation prior to them.

And what were we treated to this election cycle? While Romney’s platform supported parents and students over union prerogatives, neither candidate ran on the issue of ensuring children are educated by whatever means necessary. It almost seems it’s not politically correct to acknowledge that Republicans do something about education reform, while Democrats are forced to negotiate with their supporters, always to reduced effect.

So now what? Republicans should be loudly boasting of their continuing leadership. They can rip a page from the playbook of Jeb Bush. He challenged the education establishment, pushed and later enacted school choice programs and tough evaluations for schools and teachers in Florida, and won handily – twice! In the last election cycle, solid, reform-minded Governors were elected in 18 of 37 states. This election brought another two. These Governors appealed to minority voters who, exit polls tell us, helped President Obama. They could help future Republican candidates.

And think of the women voters who helped sweep President Obama back into the White House. Rather than hearing about vital education issues, women were told someone was tampering with their rights.

This was a colossal missed opportunity: Our polls show it is women between the ages of 25 and 45, not yet moms but intending to be, who consider educational choice almost as critical as any other issue. The Romney education agenda was more in line with the views of women, Hispanics and even African-Americans. But we only began to hear about in the final days of the campaign. By then it was too late to go to Cleveland to discuss the importance Republicans place on empowering parents to make better education choices. Too late to articulate that Republican leadership yielded, and continues to yield, the strongest charter laws. Too late to make the point that performance pay and accountability are issues Republicans took up, in the face of strenuous objection from the unions (who campaign for their opponents).

This is what they should have done. This is what they still could do. Next time.

Charter Schools Coming to Washington

“Wash. becomes 42nd state to allow charter schools”
by Donna Gordon Blankinship
Associated Press
November 12, 2012

Washington voters have narrowly approved an initiative that clears the way for up to 40 charter schools to be opened in the state over the next five years.

Initiative 1240 has clung to a narrow lead as more ballots were counted following last week’s election.

This is the fourth time the proposal has been on the ballot in Washington state, where voters rejected charter schools in 1996, 2000 and 2004.

Supporters say the charter proposal would offer new choices for struggling kids and their families. Opponents say charters have a mixed track record in other states and they would take away money from regular public schools.

Proponents of charter schools raised more than $10 million to promote the idea, including $3 million from Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates.

Washington becomes the 42nd state to allow the public independent schools.

“This is really another signal from voters that they want more options and faster change from our public education system,” said Shannon Campion, executive director of the Washington chapter of Stand for Children, one of the groups supporting the initiative.

Under the terms of the initiative, any nonprofit organization could start a charter school in Washington if their plan is approved by either a new statewide commission or by a local school board that has been authorized by the state school board to approve charter schools.

The schools would need to be free and open to all students just like traditional public schools. They would receive public funding based on student enrollment, just like other schools. But public charter schools would be exempt from some state regulations, including some of the rules regarding the hiring and firing of teachers.

Los Angeles Parents RALLY Today

Charter Schools are under attack by LAUSD once again. Students, parents and charter schools NEED YOUR HELP tomorrow, Tuesday November 13!!!

When: Tuesday, November 13 at 11 A.M.

Where:  Los Angeles Unified School District office

333 South Beaudry Avenue, Los Angeles.

Why:  LAUSD Board members will be voting on a resolution that could freeze charter school growth in Los Angeles and hurt schools already in existence.

LAUSD Board Member Steve Zimmer introduced a resolution on Charter Authorizing and Oversight that proposes to create a new Charter Oversight Commission, require the use of the LAUSD student system ISIS and halt the approval of new charter schools.

It is important that you attend the rally and encourage your friends, family and school community to attend.

Be sure to KEEP THE PRESSURE ON too, by calling and emailing LAUSD Board Members to vote “NO” on Steve Zimmer’s Resolution.

Steve Zimmer    steve.zimmer@lausd.net    213-241-6387
Marguerite Poindexter LaMotte    marguerite.lamotte@lausd.net    213-241-6382
Monica Garcia    monica.garcia@lausd.net    213-241-6180
Tamar Galatzan    tamar.galatzan@lausd.net    213-241-6386
Bennett Kayser    BoardDistrict5@lausd.net    213-241-5555
Nury Martinez    nury.martinez@lausd.net    213-241-6388
Dr. Richard Vladovic    richard.vladovic@lausd.net    213-241-6385

 

For more information visit Granada Hills Charter High School’s website or visit Families That Can.

Please take 30 seconds NOW to forward this Alert to at least 10 of your friends.

Every bit helps!

Daily Headlines for November 13, 2012

School Choice Victories
Wall Street Journal, November 12, 2012

Election Day was a bad one for Mitt Romney but a good one for education reformers in Washington state and Georgia and for anyone who believes in the primacy of school choice.

FROM THE STATES

COLORADO

Proposed Charter Schools Detail Offerings For D-11
Colorado Springs Gazette, CO, November 12, 2012

Organizers of three proposed charter schools are seeking to join Colorado Springs School District 11’s family of seven charter schools.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

A Much-Needed Pruning Of D.C.’s Overbuilt School System
Washington Post, DC, November 12, 2012

EVEN BEFORE DETAILS are released, critics are circling to attack the school-closing proposal that D.C. Schools Chancellor Kaya Henderson will release Tuesday. The shuttering of a beloved school can be one of the hardest blows to a neighborhood. But some schools have to close, and facts ought to trump emotion or nostalgia in the process.

FLORIDA

Teachers’ Union Questions VAM Data
Highlands Today, FL, November 13, 2012

The state teachers union claims the data used to evaluate teachers is insufficient and possibly inaccurate and wants Gov. Rick Scott to put the new evaluation system on hold this year.

GEORGIA

How Tybee Island Got Its School Back
Savannah Morning News, GA, November 13, 2012

Tybee Maritime Academy Charter School is scheduled to open next year. The sleepy island community hasn’t had a school since tiny St. Michael’s closed three years ago. The determined residents who spent two years planning, petitioning and raising money for a charter school are working to make sure the facility is ready to welcome children back.

IDAHO

Luna Calls Election Defeat ‘Bump In The Road’
Idaho Statesman, ID, November 12, 2012

Teachers throughout Idaho will get bonuses to recognize last year’s work despite the defeat of Idaho’s merit pay law in the Nov. 6 election, Idaho schools Superintendent Tom Luna said Monday, but about $50 million set aside for other Students Come First programs this fiscal year could fall by the wayside.

ILLLINOIS

Quest Charter School Wants To Change Fees
Peoria Journal Star, IL, November 12, 2012

District 150 pays the charter school 85 percent of standard tuition costs to operate the school, according to Barton. “Now that’s got to be modified to reflect our occupancy costs.”

Teachers Union Marches Against School Closings
Chicago Tribune, IL, November 13, 2012

As it girds for a battle over school closings, the Chicago Teachers Union is adhering to the strategy it employed during the September strike by framing the fight as one pitting regular Joes from the neighborhood against elitist big-money interests.

A Challenge Unmet
Chicago Tribune, IL, November 12, 2012

Students with emotional or learning disabilities are entitled to an education. But in Chicago, they often miss weeks of school, more than other children

INDIANA

More Accountability For Charter Schools
The Journal Gazette, IN, November 13, 2012

Ball State University is on the right track in expanding the scope of its charter school reviews. In weighing renewal of its three Fort Wayne schools this year, the university shouldn’t hesitate to hold the schools to the promise on which the state’s charter law was built: Outperform traditional public schools or close.

Marshall Academy Chief Quits
The Journal Gazette, IN, November 13, 2012

After less than six months on the job, Thurgood Marshall Leadership Academy’s principal has resigned to take a job in Fort Wayne Community Schools.

LOUISIANA

Taylor Offers Choice
The Advocate, LA, November 13, 2012

East Baton Rouge Parish Superintendent Bernard Taylor is suggesting creating two new magnet programs and expanding a third in the north Baton Rouge neighborhoods near Capitol High School.

Data Shows Louisiana Schools’ Hiring and Benefits – Not Vouchers – the Cause of Budget Woes
Pelican Post, LA, November 12, 2012

Scholarship critics ignoring the real culprits: more staff for fewer students and skyrocketing benefits

MASSACHUSETTS

Charter School Purchase In Works
Newburyport Daily News, MA, November 13, 2012

After looking around to purchase a permanent school site for several years, the River Valley Charter School Board of Trustees has decided there’s no place like home.

MICHIGAN

Judge: Charter Violated Rules
Detroit News, MI, November 13, 2012

A judge has ruled that the Highland Park charter schools system is in violation of the state’s Open Meetings Act for failing to notify a district board member about meetings and not releasing other information.

Jackson Community College Will Explore Authorization of ‘Early College’ Charter School At Urging of Parents
Jackson Citizen Patriot, MI, November 12, 2012

Jackson Community College officials are investigating the possibility of authorizing and overseeing an “early college” charter school that could possibly open as early as this fall.

MISSISSIPPI

House Panel Member’s Removal Could Sway Charter School Vote
Jackson Clarion Ledger, MS, November 12, 2012

State House Speaker Philip Gunn has removed Rep. Linda Whittington from the Education Committee, a move that could sway the committee’s vote next session to pass a charter schools expansion bill.

A Second Chance For Mississippi Charter Schools
The Hechinger Report Blog, November 12, 2012

Republicans in Mississippi intend to fight for charter schools during the 2013 legislative session, renewing a contentious battle from last year’s session.

NEW YORK

Charter Plans: Needed Rescue Or Hostile Takeover?
Buffalo News, NY, November 13, 2012

It’s either a much-needed rescue or a hostile takeover, depending on whom you talk to. There doesn’t seem to be much middle ground on the proposal to close East High School and Waterfront Elementary as district schools and reopen them as charter schools.

NY Group Pushes For Open Enrollment, School Choice
Elmira Star Gazette, NY, November 12, 2012

An Albany-area research group is calling for a statewide open enrollment program that gives parents a choice of public schools for their children.

OHIO

Groups Get Ready To Fight For Schools
Columbus Dispatch, OH, November 13, 2012

There’s another big fight coming over school funding. More than 15 years after the Ohio Supreme Court ruled that the way the state funds public education is unconstitutional, state leaders continue to tinker with the school funding.

OREGON

Why Albany Is In Need Of A Charter School
Albany Democrat Herald, OR, November 12, 2012

As the paper recently stated, the Albany School Board is considering a proposal for a charter school in Albany . I hope the following comments, which I have shared with the school board members, will help readers understand the opportunity this charter school offers to all in our community.

PENNSYLVANIA

Philly Catholic Schools Start A Marketing Campaign
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, November 13, 2012

Choose My Future, a new archdiocesan marketing campaign, aims to boost enrollment in the 17 Catholic high schools of the Archdiocese of Philadelphia through online and radio advertisements. A newly retooled website also informs potential students.

Chester Upland School District Recovery Plan Hints At Returning Art And Music Classes
Philadelphia Inquirer, PA, November 13, 2012

Children in the struggling Chester Upland School District could see art and music classes restored as soon as this school year, according to a financial and academic recovery plan that will be released Tuesday.

A+ Report Gives Pittsburgh Public Schools Mostly Bad Grades
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, November 13, 2012

Pittsburgh Public Schools superintendent Linda Lane knew she would get bad news in the annual report of A+ Schools, which Monday outlined declines in achievement, the graduation rate, number of students qualifying for Pittsburgh Promise scholarships and reduction in college readiness in her district.

Future Uncertain For Alternative High School In Suburbs East Of Pittsburgh
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, PA, November 13, 2012

Then she heard from a friend about the Boyce Campus Middle College High School , an alternative school with a smaller enrollment and the opportunity to take college classes while still in high school, and she jumped at the chance to attend.

Area School Boards Move To Denounce State Education Chief
The Morning Call, PA, November 12, 2012

Bethlehem Area and Salisbury Township districts say Ron Tomalis’ policies favor charters at the expense of traditional public schools.

TENNESSEE

Great Hearts Still May Have Future In Nashville
The Tennessean, TN, November 13, 2012

The Metro Nashville school board is expected to vote tonight on whether to offer an olive branch to Great Hearts Academies, the controversial charter school it has denied three times.

Three Memphis Charter Schools In Jeopardy For Poor Grades
Commercial Appeal, TN, November 12, 2012

Three Memphis charter schools could be closed based on poor test scores, including Memphis Academy of Science and Engineering, once a flagship performer.

Bipartisan Work Helps Schools Improve
The Tennessean, TN, November 13, 2012

The 2012 election season has painted a picture of a deeply divided America , but as President Obama reminded us, “we are not as divided as our politics suggests.” And one effort where both sides of the political aisle have been increasingly aligned is the quest to transform our public schools.

VIRGINIA

Criticism Mounts Over Va. Plan To Close Achievement Gap
WVEC, VA, November 12, 2012

New math testing rates set by Virginia education officials are under fire by members of the Virginia Legislative Black Caucus and the president of the Norfolk Federation of Teachers, Thomas Calhoun.

Charter School Law Precludes Innovation
Free Lance-Star, VA, November 12, 2012

Today, there are more than 5,600 public charter schools in the U.S. , serving 2 million schoolchildren. In Virginia , there are exactly four, with a combined enrollment of 423 students.

WASHINGTON

Charter Schools Narrowly Win Approval In Washington
Seattle Times, WA, November 12, 2012

Initiative 1240, the measure that will allow 40 charter schools to open in Washington state, has passed.

Legal Challenges Ahead For Charter Schools?
KPLU, WA, November 12, 2012

Now that charter school backers have declared victory, opponents are readying possible legal challenges to the new law established by Initiative 1240.

ONLINE SCHOOLS

Virtual School Driving Enrollment Growth In Lawrence
Lawrence Journal World, KS, November 12, 2012

Enrollment in the Lawrence school district grew slightly more than budget officials had projected earlier this summer, which means they’ll have about $57,000 more to spend in the current school year than they had budgeted in August.

Hall County Board Of Education Looking Into Virtual Classes
Gainesville Times, GA, November 12, 2012

More Hall County students could take classes completely online — on their schedule and from anywhere — as early as next semester.